The Intellectual Premium: On Literary Fashion

Umberto Eco’s Library in Bologna, Italy, 2026, Photograph, Getty Images

There’s a clamor in the culture to show off one’s literary bona fides. The “intellectual” has gained a heightened status. Celebrities are hiring book stylists — professionals who select texts for their clients to carry in public when they anticipate being photographed, or to display prominently on their shelves. Vogue is publishing articles on what models are reading backstage at Fashion Week. And last month, Valentino’s latest collection was presented under the title “Antibiblioteca: Catalogue of the Unread.” Guests were asked to bring their favorite books, posing with them as they arrived at the show venue, Bibliothèque Sainte-Geneviève.

Brands, both individuals and fashion houses, crave new ways to exude depth. They’re reaching for what can only be described as a cultural thickness, something substantial that implies the brains behind their products are capable of erudition. While every conventional status marker of celebrity is now seemingly imitable — designer bags, tropical vacations, cosmeticized faces — the rich interiority that books signal is becoming increasingly scarce. That makes them powerful cultural capital and the next frontier for commercialization. There’s an Intellectual Premium in the market for status goods — and people.

The standard “influencer” exemplifies, fairly or not, the life of a person whose behavior is shallow, overexposed, and crafted for consumption: the made-up face constantly appearing on a feed, the full home tour, the camera always cataloging one’s “lifestyle” for our viewing pleasure, even those moments once considered sacred in a human life. Likewise, the proliferation of fast fashion and the apparent ubiquity of material wealth — even if a mere illusion propagated in the funhouse of Instagram — have created an oversaturated ecosystem where anyone can participate in trends and show off their designer outfits. (Consider the fake private-jet photo studios in New York City and Los Angeles.) There are seemingly so many beautiful people loudly living beautiful lives as to make it all look banal.

Status, which by definition requires scarcity, has to migrate. The high-status person must now exist in a wholly different territory than this e-culture ennui, so they find new ways of distinguishing themselves. Instead of boring us with predictable yacht photos off the Amalfi Coast, they’re opting to post vacation reads and personal Substack essays. The irony is that the cerebral introvert, a bookish character cast for decades as the peripheral underdog in popular media, has gained sex appeal that Italian high fashion houses want to sell.

A friend told me that she’d gone out with a man in part because, despite being a well-known designer, he had a private social media account with under 1,000 followers. He spent his time creating clothes and learning about his craft. His privacy and time spent offline were more valuable to him than posting, which he rarely did. This attracted her. As British Vogue put it in a recent article: “There’s No Cool Way To Be On Instagram Anymore.” We’ve arrived in a time when a once-coveted high follower count can now be a turn-off. Relentless exposure is not sexy anymore, but depth is.

Fashion houses and their creative directors understand this. They see that the “Hot Literati” have become a new aspirational class in the media. Miu Miu is now hosting a literary club in Milan, and Coach is selling “book charms” — fully readable hardcover texts to attach to a luxury handbag (titles include Sense and Sensibility and I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings).

But the learning these charms supposedly symbolize isn’t easy to acquire. True deep reading is a personally defining, formative practice. To produce a singular mind, one must direct one’s attention carefully over the span of years or decades. This project may entail the careful digestion of great books and prolonged grappling with odd philosophical texts. Perhaps, for the designer with the private Instagram, it entails carefully honing a craft. Itentails many hours spent alone, focused on the diligent pursuit of one’s curiosities — no matter the domain. There is great joy in encountering a person with such a mind, something nearly addictive in the impossible task of fully exploring their idiosyncratic inner landscape. Unobservable are the paths they have taken, the strange provenance that has formed them.

We desire these people because we sense a mysterious, irreducible remainder that we cannot fully know or possess — the only space where intrigue can survive. The attraction lies, in part, in the possibility that one might discover another way of seeing the world through their eyes. And whether intentionally or not, such a person also symbolizes the rejection of a shallow, chronically online culture: the years spent developing an inner world cannot be posted. It’s private time that must have been spent off the grid. These people have refused the dictates of an algorithm designed to monopolize their attention until, as the phrase goes, they’re “brain-rotted” like the rest of us.

The opposite of brain rot might be intellectual curiosity. The idea behind Valentino’s aforementioned fashion show — “Antibiblioteca: Catalogue of the Unread” — comes from the writer Umberto Eco, a novelist and philosopher who believed that to be intellectually curious was to truly be alive. Eco owned a private library in Milan containing over 30,000 books spanning many large rooms, with volumes stacked from floor to ceiling. In Nassim Taleb’s telling in The Black Swan, the point of the library was to keep Eco intellectually humble: he had not read the vast majority of the books he owned, and he would never be able to within his lifetime. The library served as a research tool rather than an elaborate trophy displaying what had already been mastered. Taleb referred to this as an anti-library.

The books on the invitations to the Valentino show bore titles that did not actually exist. Every guest was thus put in the same position as Eco facing his shelves: non-reading was the throughline. But what separates Umberto Eco and his fellow readers from the book stylists’ clients is what the pages they did read have done to them. How were they changed by what they encountered?

Eco’s unread books were oriented toward knowledge he had yet to acquire, whereas Valentino’s were oriented toward an audience. We’re attracted to the “intellectual” because we cannot see all the way into them, yet to commercialize their intellectualism, they somehow have to show us this opacity. The thickness that the designers and book stylists seek to capture cannot be grasped without vanishing. There’s a hollowness to the performance of learning: the mind’s provenance cannot be neatly packaged for sale without losing the quality that made it desirable.

Listening to Troye Sivan’s “Party” play loudly in the background at the Valentino show, I was reminded of a quote from Eco. “You cannot find God where there is noise,” he said in a posthumous 2022 documentary. “God is not to be found in mass media, nor on newspapers’ front pages; God is never on TV.” A book can become an accessory, but the moments spent away from all the noise can never be.

Savannah (“Sav”) Huitema is a New York City-based writer, attorney, and fashion model. She serves as Style Critic at The Metropolitan Review.