Is This How the World Ends?: On Robert Coover’s The Brunist Day of Wrath

Robert Coover in Venice, Italy, 2009, Photograph, Getty Images

In a little while,
I shall have won,
The entire battle
Will at once be done.
Then I may rest
In halls of roses
And unceasingly,
And unceasingly
Speak with my Jesus.

(Headstone of Søren Kierkegaard)


In Robert Coover’s debut novel, The Origin of the Brunists, a coal mine — that violation of Mother Nature, in which poorly-paid men with dirty faces and sore joints scour the caliginous darkness for precious, planet-choking rocks to make money to gas up their trucks to get to the mine where they break their backs in underground carboniferous tunnels again the next day, and the next — collapses, like a dream grown antiquated. Ninety-seven people die. The sole survivor, Giovanni Bruno, an “idiot” who makes it out alive because of stupid luck (but isn’t stupid luck key to the American Dream?), is heralded as a man obviously godly and important, his continued existence a miracle: “With his buddy Collins nailed to the earth and maybe dying, Bruno had cut and run to save his own skin. . . .” A worker and amateur preacher named Ely Collins sees a luxuriant white bird come to him, a divine vision, and leaves a note to his wife. When Bruno is excavated from the mine, the fallen Ely’s experience and Bruno’s miraculous survival inspire a new cult: the Brunists, a kind of Christian sect who believe unwaveringly — and, to the rest of the town, those who aren’t eventually persuaded at least, distressingly — that the end is nigh.

Bruno’s influence will soon grow powerful and pervasive. Of course, in the flummoxing wake of tragedy, Americans cling to archaic beliefs in the impossible being possible, or, like the Brunists, affix their hopes to a new, exciting belief system. With amazement and unfeigned certainty, they see omens and icons and metaphors and find meaning in the meaningless. Their faith cannot be deterred by anything said by anyone. Like all important men, Bruno provokes feelings — antagonism, love, fear, hate — in just about everyone. His ascension to holy bellwether is inevitable.

Also inevitable is the violence spurred by the Brunist cult, the longing for a day of reckoning they are so sure is impending. In their desperate search for ascension, they fall — and rise again.

The lionization of moronic Giovanni Bruno is a wry, irreverent reference to Giordano Bruno, who was, according to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “one of the most adventurous thinkers of the Renaissance,” a jack-of-all-trades intellectual whose mystical ideas and cosmological theories helped advance Copernican heliocentrism. Bruno advocated for pantheism and posited ideas on metempsychosis regarding the reincarnation of the soul (see the similarities?), which pissed off the Catholic leaders and led to him being burned at the stake at Campo de’ Fiori in 1600. Whereas Giordano was consumed by fire for his heresy, Giovanni is heralded as a hero, a prophet, the vessel through which God shares his enigmatic messages on love and light and the end of all things. Both burn bright in their own ways.

Coover, who won the 1967 William Faulkner Foundation Award for Notable First Novel for The Origin of the Brunists, was born Feb. 4, 1932, in Charles City, Iowa. His father was a newspaper editor, and they lived a peripatetic life. Coover spent two years at Southern Illinois University in Carbondale, then studied Slavic at Indiana University, and then joined the Navy, during which time he married María del Pilar Sans Mallafré, who changed her name to Pilar Sans Coover. They moved back to America, and he earned a master’s degree from the University of Chicago. The extent to and ways in which Coover inserted himself into his fiction is a little tricky to ascertain. In a 2004 interview with McSweeney’s, he said:

My favorite literary biography is that of Shakespeare. Read it as a model. He never let it out that he was “raised” in Iowa, or wherever (though I am sure Iowans would be happy to claim him, and it would make complete sense to them) — he’s a giant in the author-interview field. We don’t even know if he wrote the plays attributed to him. For that matter, we don’t know if I’ve written the books attributed to me. I might just be another Joyce Carol Oates nom de plume, like half the rest of my generation.

Coover is known for his postmodern innovations, and his oeuvre is dizzyingly eclectic in aesthetic style and ostensible subject of plot, but one consistent subject is his understanding of and fondness for American idioms. In language, formal and casual, he finds the country’s essence, its vitality, its beauty and tainted, tawdry purposes, the ways its fallacies and lies evince honesty which is sometimes unintentional. Intentions and consequences. His most famous and maybe still best novel, The Public Burning (though my personal favorite of his books is the collection A Night at the Movies), is a seething, trenchant pasquinade of midcentury American politics, in which Tricky Dick Nixon is both an intensely insecure and jealous loser spewing vitriol and flummery about all the bullies and assholes of the world conspiring against him, and a sad loser depicted with more empathy than any serious writer of fiction had, at that point, ever dared. (Norman Mailer, titan of American letters, wrote about Nixon better than anyone, but his writing on Tricky Dick is considered nonfiction.)

Consider also The Universal Baseball Association, Inc., J. Henry Waugh, Prop., in which a fantasy baseball league (not today’s kind of fantasy league, but one literally existing only in a man’s fantasies) has been conjured in the fervent imagination of an unhappy accountant; he finds in his fantasy games (the players with vividly distinct personalities and playing styles and careers complete with carefully kept stats), not just a reprieve from the tedium of an unfulfilling life, but a new meaning for life. America’s pastime as ontological rejuvenation is a game of numerous linguistic idiosyncrasies and catchphrases — going, going, gone!

In The Brunist Day of Wrath, baseball represents failure, deflated dreams, the inevitability of hope defeated. As honky-tonk singer Duke tells his new lady friend in a dingy dive bar:

I had this guy I useta play ball with. He was a pitcher like me, and though he couldn’t throw as hard, he was trickier and sharper — he could smash a fly on a barn door at sixty feet — and he actually got a brief sniff at the big time. He was specially good at a inswingin’ curve so sharp it could break batters’ fingers on the bat, but that was his undoin’ cuz them batters got pissed off and begun sendin’ line drives straight back through the mound, aimin’ at his dome. He was too quick fer ’em but eventually they nailed his pitchin’ shoulder and he ended up workin’ in a doughnut factory.

The Brunist Day of Wrath has none of the meta-fabulist shenanigans of his previous works. It is a different kind of creature, yet simpatico with Coover’s lifelong affinities. A return to his roots, but now with almost five decades of developed skills. In the five years since the Brunists fled, West Condon has become a forlorn vicinage, “like some kind of nightmare movie.” Not that it was ever bustling or cool; its inhabitants — the ones left — are dispirited, penurious, crestfallen and angry, some afraid of or deeply ireful toward the Brunists, some, in their desperation, and in defiance of their neighbors’ denunciation, persuaded by its glowing promises of salvation at the encroaching end of the world. West Condon’s roads are lined with dilapidated businesses and homes — the ones not vacated — fallen into disrepair and hopelessness, as the denizens drink, make bets at the pool hall, drive beaten and bedraggled trucks on roads riddled with potholes, and share stories of better days and the cataclysmic event — the Brunists’ unfulfilled promise of cataclysm — that provoked the town’s downfall. A downfall long in the making, and which was perhaps ineluctable, but hastened by the cultists.

Can the prophecy fulfill itself?

Day of Wrath is funny, often side-splitting in the ways Coover wrangles the English language and depicts the badinage of unremarkable small-town Americans — their selfishness and squabbles — but it is not necessarily satire or parody. Excruciatingly human, it plunges into the deepest depths of the American soul to dig up empathy for all these unremarkable nobodies mired in the melancholy of a dead town and these radical zealots whose unflappable beliefs may make no sense to us, or irritate, or even garner our ire, but mean something profound to the faithful. Empathy, but without fear to show us everyone’s ugly side. Coover takes his sweet time exploring the town (“dirtier and more shrunk up” than it used to be) and the heterogeneous populace, people at once disparate and bound by shared hardship, the beliefs of the Presbyterians (whose new minister, the Rev. Joshua J. Jenkins, is the subject of the prologue) and Catholics at once incongruous yet rooted in the same hopes, the same desire for moral goodness, and susceptible to the same sin. In Jenkins’ prologue, Coover writes about the “sequence of disruptive church schisms and rationalist heresies that followed upon the Awakening’s excessive evangelism through the convulsions of the American nineteenth century, so shaped by Presbyterian thought (and, one might say, confused by it as well), out of which musings he hopes to craft his inaugural sermon. . . .” The previous pastor, the Rev. Wesley Edwards, has been slowly but undeniably losing his mind, as his wife, Debra, who has grown resentful because of the children he has never made with her, has been drawn toward the Brunists, and leaves both her husband and religion to join the cult. A sentence from Coover’s next novel, Huck Out West, comes to mind: “When you’re living with a mob of other people, it’s hard not to fall into thinking like as they do, and then you ain’t YOU no more.”

Coover began taking notes for a sequel to The Origin of the Brunists shortly after it was published, periodically scribbling ruminations over the years, but didn’t roll up his sleeves and dive wholly into the project until the unholy advent of Christian hegemony during George W. Bush’s reign. Speaking with the Believer magazine in 2015, Coover elucidated the genesis of The Brunist Day of Wrath:

It’s a kind of pattern of my writing that I’ve tended to jot down notes or outline a little something and set it aside and not come back to it till years later. That pattern of letting things hibernate for a while has been a long one. In the case of The Brunists, it was more difficult, because I had left behind that kind of writing. In fact, I left it behind before I began the first book, and had to kind of fight off the desire to get into the writing (that became difficult for everyone) to complete it. So as I was doing that, I just naturally thought of other possible books that might spring from it — some of them not at all part of what’s happened since, some of them are close to what has happened. . . . It kind of happened then, at the turn of the millennium, when all these evangelicals turned out to support Bush and the country was talking, as a country, in these strange terms. Quite crazy, actually. They were actually talking as if this was the natural way to talk. They would be interviewed on the morning shows or the evening news or whatever, CNN, reporters, all day long. They would tend to treat the way they were speaking as a quite reasonable way to talk. So I thought if I was ever going to do it, I should do it now.

The gargantuan tome that would eventually manifest was a lifetime of literary lessons and writerly maturation, the novel toward which he had been working his whole career, a return to the beginning and, despite not being his final novel (he lived to 92), a beautiful capstone to a diverse career essential to American literature. It is long, it is dense, it is colloquial and sprawling and carefully, assiduously structured, and it is deeply, thoroughly, tragically, fearlessly American. It is also, compared to Coover’s more esoteric postmodern work, very readable, if you can keep track of who is who. The cast of characters is huge. It would take a long time to go through them all, so here are just a few of the many.

Take the Rev. Hiram Clegg, the plump, silver-haired bishop of the state of Florida and president of the International Council of Brunist Bishops, “the most successful of all the Brunist missionaries.” When Clegg “smiles, he shows all his teeth, and they are very white.” Or Ted Cavanaugh, town banker and head of the Board of Deacons, who is struggling hard with the Brunists, whose influence he fears but against whom he is, with the current situation and all the intricate (and for him, unfortunate) legalities involved, unable to do anything. He is a romantic in his own way:

As Ted has explained to Stacy (she thinks golf is funny), he loves golf as he loves every competitive sport, including banking and life itself (“And love?” she asked, and though ordinarily he would have laughed and said, sure, that most of all, he found himself momentarily voiceless — this is not a game, he was thinking), but there is something different about golf. Though she said she used to be a Quaker like the rest of her family, Stacy is not a religious person, so he couldn’t explain it in those terms, and he had to fall back on the idea of beauty, with which he was anything but comfortable. Music, painting, books failed to move him. But a long completed pass or an explosive run through a swarm of tacklers, or watching his son sink a game-winner from the halfway line as the buzzer sounded, that was beautiful. And a golf course, when used as one, that is to say, purposefully, not merely as a park to walk in, is beautiful, can be. A revelation (he didn’t say this) of God’s bounty, His love of a moral order.

And there is John P. Suggs, “not a humorous man, not even meanly so.” He owns “adjacent lands,” and is “planning to develop the site as an industrial park or strip it for coal or both. Suggs is destroying the countryside. . . . ” He shows us how everyone in town is always thinking about, talking about, trying in their own selfish ways to understand everyone else, or, rather, to posit their own ideas about everyone and fabricate motivations, ambitions, meaning. They pass judgment. To him:

Ted Cavanaugh is an immoral liberal humanist, a country-clubbing hypocrite who uses religion cynically as a power tool, a legalistic destroyer of basic civil liberties who makes the rules convenient to himself that others have to play by, an unrepentant sinner and unscrupulous manipulator and usurer — in short, a damned banker like all bankers.

Georgie Lucci is a manipulative bum, a man — though in temperament a boy — who grifts and lies and gabs. (He’s also a failed baseball player.) He doesn’t have friends as much as he has acquaintances who make marks for possible thievery. He goes around town telling everyone tall tales about his sordid hijinks in New York, his salacious endeavors, his success, looking for free booze and handouts, for “some kind of affirmation,” only to find that no one is in a position to do so, or just doesn’t want to. There are Cheese Johnson, Cokie Duncan, Steve Lawson, Buff Cooley, Georgie’s cousin Carlo Juliano, and Bert Martini, who . . .

lost his left arm in the mine accident, the one he used to catch baseballs with, so even in draw poker he leaves his cards face down on the table, tipping up their edges briefly to read them, then tossing his quarters into the pot with the one hand he has left in life.

(Coover was always skilled at writing about sad, horny people with the propensity to lie. John’s Wife is a look at the comedic seediness of a small-town American community, and the cinematic Adventures of Lucky Pierre is a lascivious, lewd, lurid, and astonishingly baroque jaunt concerned with films and sex and films about sex. It takes its title from a Herschell Gordon Lewis nudie cutie, and itself makes the porn genre a kind of deranged and erudite artform.)

From the New Testament: “Be faithful unto death and I will grant you the chaplet of life. Whoever has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the assemblies. The one who conquers will by no means be harmed by the second death.” Edwards, who was “always a dutiful son and responsible student, and he has tried, all his life long and even now while suffering so, to be a dutiful and responsible pastor and citizen, which is to say a typical West Condon hypocrite,” has an appropriate obsession with death, as do the Brunists, who think the end is where they will find life’s chaplet. For Edwards, “Only Kierkegaard’s ‘sickness unto death’ [makes] sense to him.” Ah, death. Kierkegaard wrote The Sickness unto Death in 1849, under the pseudonym Anti-Climacus, a name that implies he is “an extraordinary Christian.” For Kierkegaard, only true religious faith can rescue the soul from the anguish of ennui. So what about faith in the end? Coover’s reference also ties Day of Wrath into Thomas Bernhard’s Extinction, the misanthropical Austrian’s final novel, in which the garrulous would-be writer Franz-Joseph Murau berates himself for his urge to read Kierkegaard in the days leading up to his mother’s funeral. People grieve in different ways — sometimes for others, sometimes for themselves. The life of the dead is placed in the memory of the living; so what if the living are praying for death?

The word “death” appears, by my count, almost 100 times in Day of Wrath; the apparition of human demise lingers, haunts West Condon, trembles the bones of the town and all the sad little nobodies and the fanatics. The word’s first use refers to a biblical quote: “But I tell you of a truth, there be some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see the kingdom of God.” The final use refers to the death penalty. Ashes to ashes.

Or, as Coover ends his novel, “Done’s done.”

Arthur Mizener, known for his indispensable biography of F. Scott Fitzgerald, famously said that modernist John Dos Passos was the only major American novelist “who has had the desire and power to surround the lives of his characters with what Lionel Trilling once called ‘the buzz of history.’” We can now say the same of Robert Coover. He saw lucidly. He understood the past, the present, the future, and the inextricable ways all inform and influence each other. Few American writers have been as astute, compassionate, and acerbic in their gaze fastened to this country and the people populating it, defining it, running it, then and now and soon and always, all that nonsense borne from the recrudescent past to the ridiculous present, forward to an unknowable future we should see coming. And here is where Coover’s irony glints like the blade in the rib: done’s not always done.

Greg Cwik has written for Reverse Shot, Bookforum, the Los Angeles Review of Books, the Southwest Review of Books, the Brooklyn Rail, the Believer, Mubi Notebook, and elsewhere.